Hello Tristan, Others,
I have been reading & tracking as closely as possible the discussions regarding the "cost of LEED" since 2001 and have always been disappointed in the ubiquitous avoidance of the cost of certification (i.e.that is, for the design team efforts, not the contractors' costs that are built into their contract or the actual LEED registration costs). I recall, sometime around 2002 the USGBC had on their website a write-up noting that design teams were reporting certification costs between $20,000 -$60,000, but, a few months after I first saw that, the USGBC took that down and never went close to that subject matter again. Nor have all thoe studies that looked at the construction cost premium (KEMAGreen, Davis Langdon, GSA, EBN, Kats,etc.). Especially with the development of the GBCI and the significant increase in bureaucracy and submittal information required (e.g. PIf1-4), I would really like to see some published consideration of this. Not that it would influence our opinion or preferred design approach, but I feel that the design teams - those that actually bring the USGBC's efforts to fruition - are too often left holding the proverbial bag, and so it would be great to see some recognition/discussion of the subject matter even if everyone agreed that it can only be dealt with on a case-by-case basis. Thanks.
Eric Johnson
271 thumbs up
March 8, 2012 - 8:24 am
Try a few of these links
http://www.cleanair-coolplanet.org/for_communities/LEED_links/Analyzingt...
http://www.ihs.gov/NonMedicalPrograms/DES/Documents/LEED_CostEvaluationS...
http://www.fypower.org/pdf/gsaleed.pdf
http://caisinfo.doe.gov/documents/uc200810VG/RSMeansGreen.pdf
Ralph DiNola wrote a great post about this back in 2001 called LEED Design Fees but it doesn't seem to be on the web anymore. Try a Google search and see if you can find it.
John Amatruda
PrincipalSOCOTEC, Inc.
April 12, 2012 - 1:06 pm
Andrew,
As the lead author for the GSA LEED Cost Study, I can tell you that it did include a section on soft costs (including a pretty detailed breakdown in the appendix). While the study is dated to some degree, it addresses the issue in a relatively comprehensive way.
Overall, I think the GSA study still has a lot of useful insights, particularly on how you approach LEED cost impacts in an overall building project. At the time it was released, it received a lukewarm response from EBN, who seemed to feel that it did not address synergies adequately. After purchasing the EBN/LEED User report, which I find much more schematic than GSA's and much harder to apply, I think the GSA report deserves a second look. It's too bad they have not decided to update the study to match the current LEED requirements - perhaps they'll do it for LEED 2012.