Hi,
I am currently pursuing this LEED credit for a mall building. Most of the parking area (>75%) is underground, and part of it has a building above and other parts have an outdoor space (a mix between vegetation and hardscape). My question is, in order to meet the minimum SRI requirement of 39 for the roof, can I consider the SRI weighted average so I can have different hardscape colors to create some contrast?
Thanks,
Julio
Julio Fernandez Amodia
5 thumbs up
August 30, 2022 - 7:26 am
Any reply on this? does someone face this conflict before?
Thanks
Summer Minchew
Managing PartnerEcoimpact Consulting
LEEDuser Expert
170 thumbs up
August 30, 2022 - 8:11 am
For Option 1. Nonroof and Roof SRI and SR weighted average approach may be used to calculate compliance. The LEED Reference guide provides examples of roof and nonroof strategies, you can use any combination.
Julio Fernandez Amodia
5 thumbs up
August 30, 2022 - 1:51 pm
Hi Summer,
I understand what you are saying. But my question was regarding option 2
Summer Minchew
Managing PartnerEcoimpact Consulting
LEEDuser Expert
170 thumbs up
August 30, 2022 - 4:05 pm
For Option 2 you only have to provide Material Description, SRI, and Initial or 3-Yr Aged Value for Parking Spaces covered by roof. If you look at the LEEDonline form for the credit you'll note that for all other covered parking space types (under vegetated roof, underground, etc) you just list the number of spaces.
Deborah Lucking
Director of SustainabilityFentress Architects
LEEDuser Expert
258 thumbs up
August 30, 2022 - 4:11 pm
The July 2022 Addendum says ""Any roof used to shade or cover parking must (1) have an aged SRI of at least 32 (if aged SRI information is not available..." so I would interpret that to also include weighted average SRI. In fact when you input the values in the calculator, what you get is the weighted average.
emily reese moody
Sustainability Director, Certifications & ComplianceJacobs
LEEDuser Expert
476 thumbs up
August 30, 2022 - 4:19 pm
I think I understand Julio's question...here's my similar project approach that was awarded for both Options:
We had an underground parking garage partially under the building and partially covered by ground-level outdoor space with hardscape and landscaping features. We treated the building roof as normal roof area, and treated the ground-level area that covered the garage as normal site calcs (not roof reflectance goals), which enabled normal product selection for varied paving/plant options.
Does that help?
Julio Fernandez Amodia
5 thumbs up
August 31, 2022 - 4:20 am
Hi,
Thanks for your responses.
@Summer. The question si if is possible to apply the weighted average approach also in option 2.
@Deborah. I am not aware of any heat island reduction calculator, I know the weighted average approach is possible for option 1 but I am not sure this approach is also possible in option 2.
@Emily. Thank you, I think this is what I was looking for. So if I am not mistaken, you obtain option 1 by applying the nonroof measures in the outdoor area above the underground parking and the High-reflectance roof or vegetated roof to the actual building roof. I still have a question, the nonroof measures include use paving materials with a SR of at least 0.33 when three-year aged information is not available. So I don't understand how option 1 was awarded without applying any reflectance goals, could you please confirm me this 0.33 have to be also included?
Thank you
emily reese moody
Sustainability Director, Certifications & ComplianceJacobs
LEEDuser Expert
476 thumbs up
August 31, 2022 - 9:42 pm
I think all of your questions above may be answered by actually seeing the Credit Form that will go with your documentation, and plugging in your takeoff and reflectance values. If your project is registered in LEED Online, it will be on the Credits page, under this Credit heading, then in the Form button.
If the project hasn't been registered yet, you can use a sample form to see what we mean. This link should take you straight to this credit's page in the online Credit Library. Scroll to the bottom right, and you'll be able to download a sample form. Use the Active Form version.
Once you plug your numbers into the form, you'll be able to play with your reflectance values to see what will actually be needed of your areas in question in order to still meet the thresholds. The weighted calcs in the forms automatically calculate for you, so you'll have a clearer idea of what areas must meet which reflectance values. In many projects, you can still earn Opt 1, even if you have some areas that don't meet the values identified in the guide--this is the weighted calc effect. For Opt 2, if you have less than 100% of your parking spaces under cover, the same seems to apply, if I understand your question and the form functionality correctly.
My projects usually have reflectance goals, but can't always meet the minimums listed in the guide. Depending on the project, and due to the weighted calc, many are still able to meet the requirements. I always plug my number in the form to check our assumptions as a sanity check.