Per page 194 of the v4 BD+C Reference Guide, the Exemplary Performance section indicates "Manage 100% of rainwater that falls within the project boundary". This is a fairly vague statement. Is there any guidance on how to achieve an EP point for this credit? Is it possible to secure an innovation point if the rainwater calculator indicates a percentage at or above 100%? Has any team had success securing an EP point for this credit? Thank you!
You rely on LEEDuser. Can we rely on you?
LEEDuser is supported by our premium members, not by advertisers.
Go premium for
Marilou Communeau
October 10, 2017 - 6:49 am
I have the same question :)
Michael DeVuono
Regional Stormwater LeaderArcadis North America
LEEDuser Expert
187 thumbs up
October 10, 2017 - 12:01 pm
I too, have the same question. I think the intent is the 100 percentile storm but I'm not positive. Because with Path 1, you are managing 100% of everything that falls on the site technically.
I'll add it to my outline for my presentation discussion at Greenbuild.
Marilou Communeau
October 12, 2017 - 6:26 am
Can someone from the LEED team can answer us please ?
Managing 100% of the rainfall on site can also stand for infiltrate the 95th percentile rain + having additional on site measures for the remaining (deeper infiltration for example, which possibly isn't the same as infiltrating 100th percentile in the superficial ground)
Michael DeVuono
Regional Stormwater LeaderArcadis North America
LEEDuser Expert
187 thumbs up
October 24, 2017 - 10:14 am
The official word is that this EP is worded poorly in the reference guide. Basically you need to manage in excess of the 99th percentile storm for your site location.
LUCY WILLIAMS
PrincipalLucy C. Williams, Architect
40 thumbs up
October 25, 2017 - 10:36 am
Michael-
Where did you get this answer from? Is there a interpretation on this?
Michael DeVuono
Regional Stormwater LeaderArcadis North America
LEEDuser Expert
187 thumbs up
October 25, 2017 - 11:51 am
No. But I have connections :)
LUCY WILLIAMS
PrincipalLucy C. Williams, Architect
40 thumbs up
October 27, 2017 - 12:22 pm
Colleagues-
I sent an inquiry into a LEED v4 coach to gain further insights on how to achieve EP for this credit. I have copy pasted their response below- hope it helps you.
To earn Exemplary Performance for this credit, project teams must manage on site 100% of the rainwater from the 100th percentile storm event computed in the Historical Data worksheet of the v4 Rainfall Events Calculator.
The "percentile" storm event is a tough concept to grasp at first. As an example, if the project must manage the 95th percentile storm event, it must manage 100% of the rainwater that is generated by the 95th percentile storm event. The same is true if the project only needs to manage the 85th percentile event (say, if it’s a zero-lot-line-project). Similarly, if E.P. is pursued, the project must manage 100% of the 100th percentile event.
Also, for LEED v4, "manage on site" means the project must reduce the volume, which cannot be achieved only through detention (i.e. slowing down the rate of the outflow). A significant change in LEED v4 is that projects no longer get credit for reducing peak flows, and instead must capture a certain volume of runoff and prevent it from leaving the site, such as by infiltrating it back into the groundwater, or reusing the runoff for some other use on the project site. Therefore, in LEED v4, simply detaining the runoff and releasing it slowly is not an acceptable means of complying with the credit.
The gathering of the historical rain data and the computation of the volume required to be managed on site are the first steps. The historical data gets entered into the calculator, and the calculator provides the "Depth" of runoff for each percentile storm event, in inches, at the top of the Historical Data worksheet. This Depth in inches is used by your civil engineer to compute the overall volume of runoff from the project site for that particular storm event (i.e., the 85th, 95th, or 100th, depending on which Option/Path the project is pursuing). That computation is based on a variety of site-specific factors, such as ground slope, land cover, and soil properties to name a few. This volume of runoff then gets entered into the top of the "Strategies" worksheet. Finally, a volume of runoff must be computed for each of the different strategies employed by the project.
It is possible that the percentage of rainwater managed on site can be greater than 100%, and this is acceptable, but will not result in additional points. Therefore, if the project team is pursuing E.P. for this credit, you must first determine the volume of rainwater for the 100th percentile storm event, and then manage an equal or greater volume within the project site.
Mark Sundstrom
December 20, 2017 - 4:49 pm
Thank you for the info, Lucy. In Colorado, State law does not allow capture and reuse of stormwater. Infiltration is typically not feasible. Does anyone know if there is an exception in Colorado that allows detention to be utilized in lieu of capture?
Michael DeVuono
Regional Stormwater LeaderArcadis North America
LEEDuser Expert
187 thumbs up
December 21, 2017 - 2:13 pm
There is no exception to this credit. Some credits, unfortunately, are just not achievable.
It's kind of crazy that pot is legal in CO, but collecting rainwater from your own roof is not :/
Tristan Roberts
RepresentativeVermont House of Representatives
LEEDuser Expert
11477 thumbs up
December 21, 2017 - 2:50 pm
Quote of the day from Mike D. :)
Mark Bloomfield
Sustainably Built1 thumbs up
February 2, 2018 - 4:59 pm
Mark, I believe that law was lifted in 2016. Also, this credit doesn't require that the water is re-used or captured in a rain barrel, simply retaining it to manage runoff. Things like porous paving and rain gardens are not illegal in Colorado and can be used to achieve points here.
Lyle Axelarris
Boston Architectural CollegeJanuary 10, 2022 - 2:35 pm
100th percentile isn't a real thing, so I've been confused by this as well. I think Michael put it well above by saying that we need to manage a storm that is in exccess of the 99th percentile.
With v4.1 offering the EP for the 98th percentile storm event, using the v4.1 credit version may be an easier (and more straight forward) compliance path.