For daylight credit, do the frits suffice as sun shading?
Or would these rooms of the building not qualify for the daylight credit or just be hindered during a simulation?
Forum discussion
For daylight credit, do the frits suffice as sun shading?
Or would these rooms of the building not qualify for the daylight credit or just be hindered during a simulation?
LEEDuser is supported by our premium members, not by advertisers.
Go premium forTo post a comment, you need to register for a LEEDuser Basic membership (free) or login to your existing profile.
Is it possible to combine Options 1 and 2 for different spaces in the same building?
What spaces are considered regularly occupied and must be included in the calculations?
What daylight simulation software can I use for LEED compliance?
My office space will have cubicles with high partitions. Should I include those in my model?
What types of glare control are acceptable for this credit?
Do I actually need to submit the USGBC Daylight and Quality Views calculator?
Can electrochromic glazing qualify as a glare control device?
David Scheer
DirectorRetroEta, Inc
LEEDuser Expert
2 thumbs up
June 26, 2019 - 12:37 pm
For LEED v4.0 daylighting, the LM83 standard specifies automated shades that block direct sun when ASE is above 10%. If your frit or any other shading strategy maintains ASE below 10% (not sure if the 20% revision last year applies to shades operation), then you won't need automated shades.
As for whether frit will hinder daylighting performance, it depends on the frit density, type and color. Many times, frit will act as a diffuser and could actually improve performance by scattering light. I would suggest running some simulations in Radiance using detailed BSDF definitions, or in Insight Lighting (Revit) using the new Glazing type in R19 or R20 with a Transmissive Roughness factor. This kind of detailed glazing spec is probably a good job for a professional daylighting designer.
Daniel Glaser
PrincipalLightStanza
LEEDuser Expert
18 thumbs up
July 11, 2019 - 4:30 pm
Hi Danielle,
In LEED 4.1 ASE scores above 10% just need an explanation of how glare is being mitigated. To my knowledge there is no guidance for the explanation, but was told by someone on the LEED EQ TAG that if you described that frit was added to mitigate glare that this thought process is all that is needed.
Although Frit does reduce the light in a building, but does not eliminate glare since direct sun still gets between the frit pattern and blinds should still operate.
ASE is poorly defined in 2012 LM-83 text since the range between 7-10% is undefined. With good solar design the blinds will rarely close and you'll get great views.
David, does Revit run sDA with the blinds operating on an hourly basis?