As our project team was performing the analysis of three products, we realized that another potentially useful strategy would be to compare three similar products and use the integrative analysis worksheet as a means to identify which of the three products is best for the project. Our team wasn't sure what outcome we were supposed to have after documenting this credit, but using it as a comparative analysis to select products could be a helpful change to the requirement.
Did anyone else encounter any ways of using this information?
Angela Nekoranik
The Sheward PartnershipJanuary 4, 2024 - 10:30 am
Hi Lisa - I'd agree that a comparative analyis of the same products from different manufacturers could be an informative study for the design team. This could be a great learning process and give insight into product background and motivate clients to select the best option. As is, I also think this credit does a good job of rewarding manufacturers that provide quantitative documentation ad helps to encourage interaction with product reps, raising awareness to the company for demand of transparency documents.
Maegan Sweeney
Interior Designer | Sustainability Project ManagerThe Sheward Partnership
6 thumbs up
March 12, 2024 - 5:06 pm
I have just completed documentation for this credit on two projects. In both instances, the project did not have the same material type (i.e. carpet, paint, tile, etc.) specificed from three different manufacturers in order to complete a comparative analysis. Personally, I see more benefit from this credit when analyzing the human health impacts. Especially for projects with a large quantity of finish materials, this complements the information collected to demonstrate compliance with Material Ingredients and Low-Emitting Materials as it relates to occupant health and safety. This information is helpful when comunicating with clients and providing measurable benefits to how these materials impact occupants in the space.