Forum discussion

IAQ Testing Stories from the Field

Curious on stories when IAQ testing for LEED or WELL didn't come back with "all clear, everything's good" results we all hope for. 

I have a project right now where we are tracking down suspicious sources and look forward to telling the full story when it's done being written. 

Thought maybe this would be a good safe space to talk about lessons learned when it comes to IAQ and get out ahead of the conversation.

Example 1: Gas ranges in kitchens. In addition to electrification of kitchens from a carbon and resource-perspective, comparing electric ignition even (let alone full electric) becomes a really easy sell when you look at it from an IAQ standpoint. Formaldehyde, PM, Carbon Monoxide... we recognize these are byproducts of combustion but willingly still invite them into our buildings and homes for some reason.  

Example 2: Electronics. Remember also how WELLv1 had those requirements for Toxic Material Reduction? I know Red List covers lots of things, but what happens on "regular" (non LBC) projects where AV / IT is bid out seperately from the scope of architectural work and what we can influence? Do we end up with Liquid crystal display screens as a source for indoor volatile organic compounds...? What about the heavy metals we know are lurking in many electronic devices? 

As we move towards more continuous monitoring, that can't be temporarily tricked into passing on a given day, I feel we're going to end up with lots more questions than we can immediately answer when it comes to our indoor air chemistry. 

0

You rely on LEEDuser. Can we rely on you?

LEEDuser is supported by our premium members, not by advertisers.

Go premium for $15.95  »

Tue, 11/09/2021 - 18:13

I have been through a number of IAQ tests, mostly on LBC projects.  I have had a variety of results and it is imperative that all project team members (especially the GC) is on board with the requirements and testing procedures for it to be successful.  Here are some first IAQ test fails I've had:
  1. The gardner who let the IAQ tester in the building had a rag in her pocket she had used to wipe the gasoline off the mowers.  All she did was open the door prior to testing but it blew the whole test and showed fumes/particulates. 
  2. Someone left a packet of wet wipes (for COVID cleaning) in a conference room.  That showed up on the test and went over the allowed minimums. 
  3. During an IAQ test, there was some minor work happening on the stairs that included some sealant.  That showed up on the test and skewed all the results.  
  4. Prior to a test in an office, a non-HEPA vaccum had been used.  It left too many particulates and threw off the PM2.5 numbers.  Changing to a HEPA vaccum for regular janitorial worked for a successful retest.  
Even small items and even LBC-level removal of formaldehyde and compliance with CDPH can cause the IAQ test results to fail.  Chris Hellstern The Miller Hull Partnership

Tue, 11/09/2021 - 18:54

When testing our office in Louisville, KY for WELL, it failed due to very high VOC levels.  Apparently, a blacktop repaving project had taken place nearby two days before the test.  We waited a few weeks to try again and passed easily.  Pay attention to what's going on outside too!

Wed, 11/10/2021 - 13:51

Ha! I did an IAQ test on a nature center right after the exterior paneling was resealed. The outside air dampers were closed to limit the migration of the odor into the building and the CO2 readings were off the charts. Came back a few short days later and retested to find everything back to normal. Good lesson to make inquiries before scheduling the testing time. L Lois Vitt Sale, FAIA, LEED Fellow Senior Vice President Wight & Company 2500 North Frontage Road Darien, IL 60561630.969.7000 | d 630.739.7514 | m 630.450.1662 | f 630.969.7979 www.wightco.com

Thu, 11/11/2021 - 15:58

Healthy IAQ in Schools: Why It's Important & How to Earn the IEQ Credits through Collaboration. This was the name of our presentation at GreenBuild 2018, with Steven Burke (Consigli Construction) and Carrie Havey (The Green Engineer). We included a video from Tom Nichols (4 Elements Group), who is an IAQ tester. He has all sorts of stories like those listed above from asphalt sealing in the adjacent parking lot to plastic wrappers from furniture delivery. He emphasizes pretesting and lots of advance planning with everyone involved.  

Tue, 11/23/2021 - 22:02

Per Lisa's comment above - anyone else want to recommend their favorite IAQ testing organization or individuals? 

Add new comment

To post a comment, you need to register for a LEEDuser Basic membership (free) or login to your existing profile.