Forum discussion

NC-2009 IDc1:Innovation in Design

LEED Healthcare EQc2 - Acoustic Environment

We are working on a small clinic, and were considering pursuing EQc2, Acoustic Environment from LEED HC as an innovation credit. We found that the project will be required to achieve an STC rating of 50 to meet the credit requirements. However, we also found that we could only meet a STC rating of 50 through the use of a proprietary assembly, which we cannot use on federally funded projects. Instead, through the use of non-proprietary assemblies, which we can use on federal projects, we can only meet a STC rating of 49, unless we add an additional layer of gyp board to make "generic" assemblies compliant. Not only does this add significant costs to the project, but it also increases the amount of material, waste and labor generated in the building's construction - all for very little additional acoustic value. This doesn't seem to be the best approach by LEED for the credit, considering projects are using BMP's to meet the credit's intent (and are really at an almost equivalent acoustic rating), but are limited as to whether the assembly used is propietary or non-propietary. Does anyone have any insight as to why this might be the case? Would LEED be open to us pursing this as an innovation credit, considering we really are meeting the credit's intent?

4

You rely on LEEDuser. Can we rely on you?

LEEDuser is supported by our premium members, not by advertisers.

Go premium for $15.95  »

Wed, 04/06/2011 - 22:07

Hi Matthew: This sounds like a good question to be asked to LEED directly. I really don't know how concerned they would be with an STC 49 vs STC 50 assembly in this situation with all of the other factors you described. Personally, it sounds like there would be a good trade-off between ever-so-slightly increased acoustic performance and more sustainable/cost-effective construction. Or you cold find that they are, in fact, wanting a minimum STC 50 assembly. I don't know what the response would be.

Add new comment

To post a comment, you need to register for a LEEDuser Basic membership (free) or login to your existing profile.